In Clearfield County v. Transystems Corp., No. 10 WAP 2025, 2026 Pa. LEXIS 774, Clearfield County (the County) filed suit against Transystems Corporation (Transystems Corp.) based on architectural and engineering plans for a jail completed in 1977. Transystems Corp. filed an Answer that asserted a defense that the trial court lacked jurisdiction because, pursuant to 42 Pa.C.S. § 5536, the County did not file its complaint within 12 years of completion of the jail. The County filed preliminary objections contending that, among other things, the doctrine of nullum tempus occurrit regi (nullem tempus) precluded the statute of repose from operating as a defense to its claims. The court agreed with the defendant and held that the statute of repose barred the County’s suit.
If the nullum tempus doctrine applies, a Pennsylvania defendant will have to defend a suit brought by the state or its political subdivisions - otherwise barred by the statute of limitations - because of the common law doctrine of, which means: no time runs against the king. Nullum tempus operates as an exception to the statute of limitations that the Commonwealth justifies by the public policy of preserving public rights and funds from public officials delaying timely filing suit. The County argued that the nullum tempus doctrine should also apply to the statute of repose.
A statute of repose puts an outer limit on the right to bring a civil action, measured not when the cause of action accrues (generally when the injury is discovered), but when the defendant commits the last culpable act. Thus, a statute of repose bars any suit brought after a specified time, even if the period runs before the plaintiff’s injury.
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania declined the County’s request to extend the doctrine of nullum tempus to the Section 5536 statute of repose. As the court concluded, nullum tempus did not permit the County to avoid the Section 5536’s statute of repose because it eliminated and abolished the right of the County to bring suit 12 years after the construction project was done. Moreover, allowing the County to invoke nullum tempus to avoid the repose period undermined the legislative judgment evidenced by Section 5536: that public policy was best served by eliminating the indeterminate potential liability of construction industry professionals after a fixed 12-year period.
Based on the holding in Clearfield County, subrogation professionals who represent government entities in Pennsylvania, should be aware that if suit against a defendant is barred by Section 5536’s statute of repose, they cannot overcome the statute by relying on the nullum tempus doctrine.
Recent Posts
- Rule It Out or Leave It Out: North Carolina Federal Court Limits Fire Investigator’s Testimony for Failing to Eliminate Competing Ignition Sources
- Texas Appellate Court Rejects Narrow Reading in Certificate of Merit Challenge
- Be Specific: Texas Court Holds Certificate of Merit Deficient for Collective Assertions of Negligence
Categories
- Texas
- Products Liability
- Experts - Certificate of Merit
- Certificate of Merit
- Statute of Limitations-Repose
- CPSC Recalls
- Construction Defects
- Contracts
- Florida
- Litigation
- New York
- Economic Loss Rule
- Pennsylvania
- Arizona
- Evidence
- Arbitration
- Negligence
- Experts - Reliability
- Damages
- Minnesota
- New Jersey
- AIA Contracts
- Indiana
- Comparative Fault
- Illinois
- Internet Terms
- Right to Jury Trial
- Anti-Subrogation Rule
- Nevada
- Kansas
- Legislation
- Landlord-Tenant
- Sutton Doctrine
- Limitation of Liability
- Waiver of Subrogation
- Uncategorized
- Warranty - UCC
- Massachusetts
- California
- Idaho
- Jurisdiction
- Damages-Personal Property
- Louisiana
- Maryland
- Colorado
- Virginia
- South Carolina
- Cargo - Transportation
- Malpractice
- Indemnification
- Spoliation
- Causation
- Tennessee
- Condemnation
- CPSC Warning
- Michigan
- Comparative-Contributory Negligence
- Contribution-Apportionment
- Rhode Island
- Product Liability
- Assignment
- Missouri
- Parties
- Public Policy
- Civil Procedure
- Res Judicata
- Damages – Personal Property
- West Virginia
- Wyoming
- Oklahoma
- Builder's Risk
- Contractual Subrogation
- Equitable Subrogation
- Georgia
- Insurable Interest
- Mississippi
- Made Whole
- Delaware
- Settlement
- Subrogation – Equitable
- Construction
- Premises Liability
- Joint or Several Liability
- Montana
- Duty
- Privity
- New Mexico
- Right to Repair Act
- Building Code
- Landlord
- Tenant
- Experts
- Experts – Daubert
- Fire
- Subrogation
Tags
- Texas
- Products Liability
- Certificate of Merit
- Contracts
- Construction Defects
- Construction Contracts
- Statute of Limitations
- Pennsylvania
- Statute of Repose
- Amazon-eBay
- Florida
- Product Liability
- Economic Loss Doctrine
- Waiver of Subrogation
- New York
- Arizona
- Experts – Daubert
- Improvement
- Comparative Fault
- Arbitration
- Litigation
- Evidence
- New Jersey
- Negligence
- Architects-Engineers
- Indiana
- Illinois
- Damages
- Louisiana
- Betterment
- Minnesota
- Experts - Reliability
- Landlord-Tenant
- Failure to Warn
- CPSC Recalls; Products Liability
- Chain of Distribution
- Spoliation
- Limitation of Liability
- AIA Contract
- Idaho
- Loss of Use
- Vehicles
- Contracts - Enforcement
- Statute of Limitations – Discovery Rule
- Massachusetts
- Circumstantial Evidence
- Nullem Tempus
- Georgia
- Nevada
- Kansas
- Maryland
- Civil Procedure
- Oklahoma
- Indemnification
- Malfunction Theory
- Sutton Doctrine
- California
- Jurisdiction
- Jurisdiction - Personal
- Damages-Vehicles
- Public Policy
- Mediation
- Anti-Subrogation Rule
- Cyber Subrogation
- Tennessee
- Delaware
- Colorado
- Negligence – Duty
- West Virginia
- Apportionment
- Incorporation by Reference
- Negligent Undertaking
- Virginia
- Statute of Limitations - Contractual
- Privity
- Statute of Limitations - Tolling
- Economic Loss Rule
- Connecticut
- Design Defect
- Gist of the Action
- Malpractice
- Causation
- Made Whole
- Condemnation
- Inverse Condemnation
- Settlement
- Statute of Limitations - Accrual
- Experts – Qualifications
- Michigan
- Water Damage
- Rhode Island
- Condominiums
- Contracts - Formation
- Non-Party at Fault
- Expert Qualifications
- Amazon
- Evidence - Hearsay
- Wisconsin
- workers' compensation subrogation
- Warranty - Implied
- Malfunction Theory; Design Defect
- Independent Duty
- Ohio
- Unconscionable
- Missouri
- Parties
- Manufacturing Defect
- Pleading
- Removal
- Entire Controversy Doctrine
- Motion to Intervene
- Res Judicata
- Subrogation; High-Net-Worth; Damages; Art; Cargo-Transportation; Anti-Subrogation Rule
- Products Liability – Risk-Utility
- Lithium-ion battery
- Internet Sales
- Anti-Subrogation Rule; Wyoming; Landlord-Tenant; Sutton Doctrine
- Sanctions
- Spoliation – Fire Scene
- Builder’s Risk
- Contractual Subrogation
- Equitable Subrogation
- Exculpatory Clause
- Gross Negligence
- Insurable Interest
- Mississippi
- Standing
- Third Party
- Accepted Work
- Montana
- Independent Contractor
- Res Ipsa
- New Mexico
- Right to Repair Act
- Damages-Code Upgrades
- Statute of Limitations - Repose
- Washington
- Implied Warranty of Habitability
- Warranty - Construction
- Joint-Tortfeasors
- AIA Contracts
- Anti-Indemnity Statutes
- Forum-Venue
- Warranty – Express
- Products Liability - Foreseeability
- Cargo-Transportation
- Contribution
- MCS-90
- Substantial Completion
- Daubert
- Experts
- Fire Investigation
- NFPA 921
- North Carolina
- Subrogation
Authors
Archives
- November 2026
- October 2026
- August 2026
- July 2026
- June 2026
- May 2026
- April 2026
- March 2026
- January 2026
- December 2025
- November 2025
- September 2025
- August 2025
- July 2025
- May 2025
- April 2025
- March 2025
- February 2025
- January 2025
- December 2024
- November 2024
- October 2024
- September 2024
- August 2024
- July 2024
- June 2024
- May 2024
- April 2024
- March 2024
- February 2024
- January 2024
- December 2023
- November 2023
- October 2023
- September 2023
- August 2023
- July 2023
- June 2023
- May 2023
- April 2023
- March 2023
- February 2023
- January 2023
- December 2022
- November 2022
- October 2022
- September 2022
- August 2022
- July 2022
- June 2022
- May 2022
- April 2022
- March 2022
- February 2022
- January 2022
