In Chubb Lloyds Inc. Co. of Tex. v. Buster & Cogdell Builders, LLC, No. 01-21-00503-CV, 2023 Tex. App. LEXIS 676, the Court of Appeals of Texas, First District (Court of Appeals) considered whether the lower court properly dismissed the plaintiff’s subrogation case by enforcing a subrogation waiver in a construction contract which was not fully executed. The contract was signed by only one of the two subrogors and was not signed by the defendant general contractor. The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s decision, holding that despite the lack of signatures, the evidence established mutual assent to the contractual terms by all parties.
The plaintiff’s subrogors, Jeffrey and Mary Meyer (collectively, the Meyers), retained defendant Buster & Codgell Builders (BCB) to expand their residence. BCB drafted a contract using the American Institute of Architects (AIA) standard form contract for residential construction. The AIA contract included, by reference, a subrogation waiver that applied to BCB and its subcontractors. Prior to beginning the work, BCB emailed Jeffrey Meyer a version of the contract that only had one signature block for both Jeffrey and Mary Meyer. Minutes later, BCB sent a second version of the contract which had a signature line for each of the Meyers. However, Jeffrey Meyer signed the first version of the contract and emailed it back to BCB. In the subject line of his email, Mr. Meyers asked that BCB countersign and return the contract. BCB did not sign and return the contract.Continue Reading
Subrogation professionals have always been looking for ways to defeat onerous waiver of subrogation provisions in contracts signed by insureds. However, even when contracts are unsigned, if there is intent when the contract is made – usually long before a loss occurs - a waiver of subrogation can doom what otherwise may have been a strong case. The Superior Court of Delaware considered such a scenario to determine whether a waiver of subrogation provision applied to a multimillion-dollar subrogation case.Continue Reading
Recent Posts
Categories
- Products Liability
- Evidence
- CPSC Recalls
- Subrogation
- Experts – Daubert
- Construction Defects
- New Jersey
- Statute of Limitations-Repose
- Causation
- New York
- Certificate of Merit
- Podcast
- California
- Experts - Reliability
- Jurisdiction
- Uncategorized
- Maryland
- Condemnation
- Negligence
- CPSC Warning
- Minnesota
- Contracts
- Anti-Subrogation Rule
- Landlord-Tenant
- Sutton Doctrine
- Waiver of Subrogation
- Rhode Island
- Pennsylvania
- Texas
- Florida
- Workers' Compensation
- Economic Loss Rule
- Cargo - Transportation
- Malpractice
- Spoliation
- Tennessee
- Water Loss
- Indiana
- Michigan
- Comparative-Contributory Negligence
- Contribution-Apportionment
- AIA Contracts
- Assignment
- Missouri
- Parties
- Public Policy
- Civil Procedure
- Product Liability
- Res Judicata
- Arbitration
- Damages
- Damages – Personal Property
- Litigation
- West Virginia
- Wyoming
- Oklahoma
- Georgia
- Limitation of Liability
- Builder's Risk
- Contractual Subrogation
- Equitable Subrogation
- Illinois
- Insurable Interest
- Mississippi
- Made Whole
- Delaware
- Settlement
- Subrogation – Equitable
- Construction
- Premises Liability
- Joint or Several Liability
- Montana
- Duty
- Privity
- New Mexico
- Right to Repair Act
- Massachusetts
- Landlord
- Tenant
- Building Code
- Arizona
Tags
- Products Liability
- Subrogation
- Evidence
- Construction Defects
- Circumstantial Evidence
- Experts - Reliability
- Experts – Daubert
- New Jersey
- Podcast
- Product Liability
- Malfunction Theory
- Subro Sessions
- Texas
- Causation
- New York
- Certificate of Merit
- Contracts
- California
- Waiver of Subrogation
- CPSC Recalls; Products Liability
- Experts
- Maryland
- Landlord-Tenant
- Jurisdiction
- Jurisdiction - Personal
- Statute of Repose
- Construction Contracts
- Negligence
- Condemnation
- Inverse Condemnation
- Louisiana
- Minnesota
- Statute of Limitations - Accrual
- Amazon-eBay
- Civil Procedure
- Georgia
- Contracts - Enforcement
- Illinois
- Pennsylvania
- Made Whole
- Experts – Qualifications
- Statute of Limitations
- Sutton Doctrine
- Water Damage
- workers' compensation subrogation
- Rhode Island
- Arizona
- Florida
- Economic Loss Doctrine
- Public Policy
- Design Defect
- Expert Qualifications
- West Virginia
- Amazon
- Negligent Undertaking
- Limitation of Liability
- Statute of Limitations - Contractual
- Anti-Subrogation Rule
- Indiana
- Tennessee
- Evidence - Hearsay
- Loss of Use
- Vehicles
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- Improvement
- Negligence – Duty
- Warranty - Implied
- Apportionment
- Privity
- Malpractice
- Statute of Limitations - Tolling
- Spoliation
- Statute of Limitations – Discovery Rule
- Malfunction Theory; Design Defect
- Independent Duty
- Ohio
- Settlement
- Michigan
- Comparative Fault
- Contracts - Formation
- Condominiums
- Non-Party at Fault
- Massachusetts
- Unconscionable
- Missouri
- Parties
- Failure to Warn
- Manufacturing Defect
- Pleading
- Removal
- Entire Controversy Doctrine
- Motion to Intervene
- Res Judicata
- Arbitration
- Subrogation; High-Net-Worth; Damages; Art; Cargo-Transportation; Anti-Subrogation Rule
- Wisconsin
- Products Liability – Risk-Utility
- Architects-Engineers
- Lithium-ion battery
- Internet Sales
- Anti-Subrogation Rule; Wyoming; Landlord-Tenant; Sutton Doctrine
- Oklahoma
- Sanctions
- Spoliation – Fire Scene
- Exculpatory Clause
- Gross Negligence
- Builder’s Risk
- Contractual Subrogation
- Equitable Subrogation
- Insurable Interest
- Mississippi
- Daubert
- Standing
- Third Party
- Accepted Work
- Montana
- Independent Contractor
- Res Ipsa
- New Mexico
- Right to Repair Act
- Workers’ Compensation
- AIA Contract
- Betterment
- Damages
- Damages-Code Upgrades
- Statute of Limitations - Repose
- Washington
- Implied Warranty of Habitability
- Warranty - Construction
- Idaho
- First Party Claims
- Joint-Tortfeasors
- Forum-Venue
- Warranty – Express
- AIA Contracts
- Anti-Indemnity Statutes
- Indemnification
- Products Liability - Foreseeability
- Cargo-Transportation
- Contribution
- MCS-90
- Substantial Completion
Authors
Archives
- May 2025
- April 2025
- March 2025
- February 2025
- January 2025
- December 2024
- November 2024
- October 2024
- September 2024
- August 2024
- July 2024
- June 2024
- May 2024
- April 2024
- March 2024
- February 2024
- January 2024
- December 2023
- November 2023
- October 2023
- September 2023
- August 2023
- July 2023
- June 2023
- May 2023
- April 2023
- March 2023
- February 2023
- January 2023
- December 2022
- November 2022
- October 2022
- September 2022
- August 2022
- July 2022
- June 2022
- May 2022
- April 2022
- March 2022
- February 2022
- January 2022