Practice Highlights
- We understand the financial and reputational risks that complex, high-stakes claims disputes present to insurers.
- We are recognized industry thought leaders and strategists in D&O and professional liability.
- We have an unparalleled network of active relationships to draw on in crafting creative solutions to complex, high-stakes claims.
Practice News
- January 16, 2012
Events
- Securities LitigationApril 26, 2012
Publications
- March 12, 2012
Directors and Officers
Corporate directors and officers and financial institutions are facing an onslaught of litigation and increasing regulatory scrutiny as well as questions about the scope of protection they might receive through corporate indemnification, and under the D&O liability insurance policies designed to respond to these exposures.
We represent professional liability insurers in high-stakes, complex claims. While most of the claims we handle arise from directors & officers liability (D&O) policies, insurers that underwrite D&O insurance typically also underwrite errors & omissions (E&O) insurance for financial institutions and financial services firms, as well as for other business professionals, including investment banks, investment advisors, accounting firms, and large law firms. For this reason, we regularly handle large E&O claims involving the same kinds of underlying litigation and governmental investigation claims activity that involve D&O policies.
Our insurer representations as coverage and monitoring counsel for D&O/FI insurer clients typically include the following component tasks:
- Following an initial assessment of the claim documents and relevant insurance coverage information, the preparation of an initial report and draft coverage position letter for our insurer client;
- Contact with the insured or defense counsel to arrange and conduct a liability, damages and coverage investigation;
- Ongoing monitoring of the litigation and regular contact with defense counsel, while maintaining a regular reporting line of communications with the insurer client;
- Damage analysis; and
- Active participation in claim settlements where client insurer funds are being contributed. These tasks require work performed at different levels of seniority and experience, necessitating a team approach to the handling of these matters.
The D&O Practice Group has an insurance practice focused on the representation of professional liability insurers as coverage/monitoring and coverage litigation counsel. Other practice specialty areas include representations of insurance brokers on regulatory, transactional and litigation matters and the defense of employment-practices claims.
Our attorneys work with primary and excess domestic U.S., European and Bermuda insurers on a wide variety of significant claims involving directors and officers of public and private companies, as well as similar kinds of reputational risk litigation involving financial institution and financial services insureds.
Our team has significant involvement with respect to some of the last decade's largest scandals involving directors and officers and financial and professional insurance, including:
- Adelphia
- Enron
- Lehman Brothers
- IPO Laddering
- Madoff-Related Litigation
- Options Backdating-Related Litigation.
- Subprime/Credit Crisis-Related Litigation
- Tyco
- Worldcom
In addition to our involvement as coverage and monitoring counsel in these complex claims, we also represent insurers in coverage litigation and arbitration arising under these types of insurance policies.
D&O insurers also call on our lawyers to assist in drafting policies and endorsements as well as in identifying risk management and risk evaluation tools to assist insurers in better managing these insured exposures.
Lawyers in our D&O Practice Group are also regularly involved in educational and insurance industry programs and seminars for D&O insurance professionals dealing with cutting-edge issues in the law and in the D&O marketplace.
Representative Matters
- Eisenhandler v. Twin City Fire Ins. Co., et al., Case No. CV 09 5031716-S (Conn. Super. Ct. Oct, 21, 2011), (granting insurer’s summary judgment motion based on the prior knowledge exclusion in a lawyers professional liability policy). We represented an insurer that denied coverage for a legal malpractice claim based on a prior knowledge exclusion. The court agreed with our client's denial and granted summary judgment in favor of the insurer.
- Modern Technologies Group Inc., et al. v. Twin City Fire Insurance Co., 2010 WL 3908685 (D.N.J. Sept. 30, 2010), (granting insurer’s motion for summary judgment based on late notice of a claim under a claims-made professional liability policy). We represented an insurer which obtained an order granting summary judgment in its favor against a limousine parts seller, denying coverage for a claim under a professional liability policy on the basis of late notice.
- Russoniello v. Twin City Fire Insurance Co., 2010 WL 2024084 (D.N.J. May 20, 2010) (granting insurer's motion for summary judgment based on late notice of a claim under a lawyers professional liability policy). We represented an insurer which obtained an order granting summary judgment in its favor against a solo practitioner, denying coverage for a claim under a lawyers professional liability policy on the basis of late notice. The court held that a letter from the lawyer’s client constituted a claim because it was a demand for money and alleged completely inadequate representation that could be considered malpractice.
- Executive Risk Indem. Inc. v. Pepper Hamilton LLP, 2008 WL 6808243 (Trial Order) (N.Y.Sup. Jan 29, 2008), rev'd by 56 A.D.3d 196, 865 N.Y.S.2d 25 (1 Dep't Sep 23, 2008), affirmed as modified by 2009 WL 3347222, 2009 N.Y. Slip Op. 07453 (N.Y. Oct 20, 2009) (granting insurers' summary judgment motions on prior notice exclusions in a lawyers professional liability policy). We represented an excess insurer which obtained an order granting summary judgment in its favor against a large law firm, denying coverage for a malpractice claim under a lawyers professional liability policy on the ground of a prior knowledge exclusion.
- Schwartz v. Twin City Fire Ins. Co. et al., 492 F.Supp.2d 308 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) judgment affirmed by 539 F.3d 135 (2nd Cir.(N.Y.) Aug 19, 2008). (granting primary D&O insurer's post-trial motion to dismiss D&O excess insurers' cross-claims for bad faith). We represented an excess insurer whose denial of coverage under a D&O policy was the subject of a bad faith action tried to a jury and successfully concluded by post-trial motions to set aside the verdict.
- Indotronix International Corp. v. Twin City Fire Ins. Co., No. 06 Civ. 2688 (S.D.N.Y. April 30, 2007) (finding after inquest on insured's claim for reimbursement of $520,000 incurred in defense costs and expenses, that only $117,000, after application of $100,000 SIR, were reasonable and necessary and therefore recoverable from D&O insurer). We represented a D&O insurer that challenged a request by the insured for reimbursement of $520,000 the insured incurred in defense costs and expenses in defending an underlying action. After an inquest before the court, the court denied the insured’s request for reimbursement of $520,000, finding that, after application of a $100,000 SIR, only $117,000 were “reasonable and necessary” and therefore recoverable from the D&O insurer.
- CNL Hotels & Resorts, Inc. v. Twin City Fire Insurance Company, et al. 06 CV 324, Order 113 (MD FL October 16, 2006) (granting insurer's motion to dismiss bad faith claim under Florida law because the insured had not first established that coverage was available for the claim in question).
- Vigilant Insurance Co. v. Credit Suisse First Boston, 10 A.D.3d 528, 782 N.Y.S.2d 19 (App. Div. 1st. Dept. 2004) (affirming trial court and extending ruling to also exclude coverage for defense costs associated with uncovered claim). We represented a quota share excess insurer in an action arising from denial of coverage on the ground of uninsurability of intentional acts and, alone among the insurers, obtained reversal on appeal of the trial court’s decision ordering payment of defense expenses.
News
- January 16, 2012
- October 27, 2011D&O Diary
- October 6, 2011
- May 24, 2010
- 2010
- Maurice Pesso Quoted by Business Insurance on Madoff's Legacy of Lawsuits and ClaimsJuly 5, 2009
Events
- Securities LitigationWebinar with Advisen Ltd.April 26, 2012
- Advisen Insurance Intelligence WebinarApril 26, 2012
- The Penn Club of New YorkFebruary 7, 2012
- Hamilton Princess Hotel (Bermuda)January 26, 2012
- Overview of Damages in Securities Class ActionsClient Continuing Legal Education Program (Hamilton, Bermuda)November 2011
- Litigation: Start to FinishClient Continuing Legal Education Program (Hamilton, Bermuda)November 2011
- The Union League Club Library (New York, NY)September 13, 2011
- The Madoff Investment Scandal – Following the Coverage TrailWhite and Williams Coverage CollegeSeptember 30, 2010
- Roundup of 2009-2010 D&O Coverage Cases and Resulting Claims-Handling StrategiesWhite and Williams Coverage College 2010September 30, 2010
- Following the Ponzi Scheme Coverage Trail: Who Pays for Madoff-Related Liabilities?Coverage College 2010September 30, 2010
- Effective Utilization of Coverage and Monitoring Counsel in Complex ClaimsWhite and Williams LLP Coverage College 2010September 30, 2010
- Effective Use of Coverage and Monitoring CounselCoverage College 2010September 30, 2010
- Coverage Litigation Strategies for D&O/Financial Institution Coverage DisputesWhite and Williams Coverage CollegeSeptember 30, 2010
- Life After Morrison: What are the Risks to European D&O Insurers from U.S. Shareholder Class Actions and Derivative Litigation?5th Annual European Forum on D&O Liability Insurance (Cologne, Germany)September 29, 2010
- Dangerous Data: Perils of eDiscovery and How to Manage ThemBusiness Insurance WebcastSeptember 29, 2010
- Following the Money Trail: How Side-A D&O Policies Are Changing the D&O Underwriting and Claims LandscapesRAA’s 2010 Re Claims SeminarSeptember 15, 2010
- Mediation and Settlement StrategiesPLI's Class Action Litigation 2009: Prosecution and Defense Strategies (New York, NY)July 9-10, 2010
- What Are the Risks to European D&O Insurers From Class and Derivative Actions in the US?D&O Liability Insurance Forum 2010March 16-17, 2010
- Insurance Coverage Issues Arising From the Subprime Lending and Credit CrisisHB Conferences TeleconferenceMarch 25, 2009
- What's Wrong with the Claims Process, ModeratorPLUS (Professional Liability Underwriting Society) D&O SymposiumFebruary 26, 2009
- The Madoff Matter: D&O Event, E&O Event, or Non-EventAdvisen WebinarJanuary 2009
- The Future of the Plaintiff's BarPLUS (Professional Liability Underwriting Society) International Conference (San Francisco, CA)November 5-7, 2008
- Coverage Issues Arising from the Subprime Mortgage LitigationMealey’s Subprime Mortgage Litigation & Insurance Coverage Conference (Washington, DC)June 19-20, 2008
- Hot Issues in D&O Claims: Subprime and Beyond2008 Swiss Re Claims Conference: Facing Future Challenges Together (Chicago, IL)June 11-13, 2008
- Subprime, Securities Class Actions, Auction Rate Securities, Hedge Funds and BeyondNew York, NYJune 2008
- Hot Issues in D&O Claims: Subprime and BeyondNew York, NYMay 2008
- SubprimeInsurance Coverage 2008: Claims, Trends & Litigation (New York, NY)April 28-29, 2008
- Insurance Coverage IssuesLexis Nexis Mealey's Subprime Mortgage TeleconferenceMarch 12, 2008
- Trends in Securities Class Actions: Is the Lull Over?New York, NYDecember 2007
- Innocent Coinsured Doctrine in Property and D&O Insurance and Reinsurance LawIntermediaries and Reinsurance Underwriters Association (New York, NY)November 2007
- Board of Directors: D&O Reform and the Impact on Large D&O Claims, ModeratorMealey’s Global Reinsurance Forum (Bermuda)November 14-15, 2007
- Coverage Issues Arising from Subprime LendingMealey's Subprime Mortgage Litigation Conference (Chicago, IL)October 29-30, 2007
- U.S. Exposure: The Protection Offered by Side-A DIC PoliciesMadrid, Spain and Paris, FranceSeptember 2007
- Mergers & Acquisitions - Hot TopicsNew York, NYJune 13, 2007
- Directors and Officers Liability InsuranceHamilton, BermudaApril 23, 2007
- Les Polices Side A DIC et Les Risques Posés Par Les Etats-UnisParis, France2007
- D&O Liability DevelopmentsReport From the Front Lines: Litigation and Regulatory Developments Affecting Public Companies, Financial Institutions and Investment Funds (Bermuda)September 27, 2005
Publications
- March 12, 2012
- January 30, 2012
- D&O Coverage in Bankruptcy Cases: The Lights Are On, But Is Anyone Home?American Bankruptcy Institute 16th Annual Winter Leadership Conference
- May 31, 2011
- March 28, 2011
- February 2011
- Addressing Coverage For SLC-Incurred Legal CostsJanuary 28, 2010Law360
- It's 2010: Do You Know Where Your D&O Policy Is?January 2010SEC Trends and Developments
- D&O Update: Court Addresses Coverage for Legal Costs Incurred by a Special Litigation CommitteeJanuary 1, 2010Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge Client Advisory
- Establishing the Foundation: Reviewing the Insurance ContractSeptember 23, 2009National Business Institute
- Getting the Deal Through2009USA Analysis Chapter, Insurance and Reinsurance
- How Bailouts Could Impact D&O and E&OSpring 2009, Issue 18Runoff and Restructuring Magazine
- Subprime Woes Shift Claim Focus to AggregationFebruary 23, 2009Business Insurance
- The New York Insurance Department Will No Longer Approve D&O Policies Lacking "Duty-to-Defend" Coverage FeatureDecember 2008Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge Client Advisory
- Excess Insurers Beware: Exhaustion of Underlying Limits May Be Closer Than You ThinkDecember 2008Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge Insurance and Reinsurance Review
- Does the Reservation of an Insurer's Right to Recoup Defense Costs Actually Entitle an Insurer to Recoupment?December 2008Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge Insurance and Reinsurance Review
- D&O and E&O Liability and Coverage Issues Resulting From Subprime ClaimsOctober 20, 2008Insurance Advocate
- Insurance and Reinsurance Issues Resulting from Subprime ClaimsOctober 2008Who's Who Legal
- Subprime Claims: D&O and E&O Liability and Coverage ImplicationsMarch 11, 2008Advisen FPN
- Insured's Breach of Consent Provisions Precludes Coverage for SettlementMarch 2008Advisen
- Current Issues in D&O and E&O Coverage InvestigationsFebruary 2008Law 360
- Insurance Coverage and the Subprime Mess: Who Pays the Cleanup Costs, Chapter Author2008Inside the Minds: Navigating The Subprime Lending Industry (Aspatore Books)
- Loan Loss Claims Under E&O and D&O PoliciesNovember 2007Loan Loss Coverage Under Financial Institution Bonds
- The Stock Options Backdating Scandal: D&O ImplicationsAugust 2007Mealey's Litigation Report
- The Stock Options Backdating Scandal: D&O ImplicationsJune 2007Risk Management Magazine
- The Eroding Privilege of an Insurer's Communications with Its Coverage CounselJune 1, 2007Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge Insurance and Reinsurance Update
- Commissions Deducted from Premium Subject to Preference LiabilityMarch 6, 2007International Law Office
- Insurance Broker Preference Liability for Commissions Deducted from PremiumDecember 2006Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge Insurance and Reinsurance Update
- Damages Exposure – Issues to Consider in Discrimination and Retaliation CasesNovember 8, 2006Employment Practices Liability Insurance ExecuSummit
- EDD: A Digital Minefield for InsurersJuly 3, 2006National Underwriter P&C
- Hold It! Recent Cases Regarding 'Litigation Hold' Procedures for Electronic Discovery Clarify When Insurers Will Pay for Such ExpensesJuly 2006Risk & Insurance
- Hot Topics in D&O Claims Handling and CoverageJune 8, 2006Association of the Bar of the City of New York
- More Digital Data Means Increase in U.S. Case LawMarch 24, 2006Insurance Day
- An Overview of Selected Director and Officer Liability Insurance Issues That Arise in the Context of Insolvencies of Insurance CompaniesFebruary 1, 2006Insolvency Workshop, International Association of Insurance Receivers
- Primary and Excess LayersJuly 8, 2005Insurance Day
- Avoiding Legal Landmines in Financial Services, Chapter Author2005Aspatore Books
- The Accident of Efficiency: Foreign Exchanges, American Depository Receipts, and Space ArbitrageSpring 200351 Buff. L. Rev. 383
- Revisiting Underwriter ProfitabilityAugust 2001News & Views, Professional Liability Underwriting Society
- Risk Management Issues for IPOsJuly 1998The Review of Securities & Commodities Regulation
- UK Boardrooms: Litigation Free ZonesJanuary 1993The D&O Book: A Comparison Guide to Directors & Officers Liability Insurance Policies
- D&O Developments, Monthly Columnist1993-1998News & Views, Professional Liability Underwriting Society
- A D&O Policy Road Map: The Coverage ExclusionsNovember 1998Insights: The Corporate & Securities Law Advisor
- Allocation of Defense Costs and Settlements Under D&O PoliciesJuly 1992Reinsurance
Practice Contacts
- John McCarrick, Chair
212.714.3072 | 914.487.7342 | Email | vCard

